Talk:Safe, sane, and consensual
From wipipedia.org
(Difference between revisions)
Interesdom (Talk | contribs) (Proposed changes to unify where content belongs and tidy up this area specifically.) |
(comment) |
||
| Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
* The sooner we change this kind of thing the better. At the moment, the effort to change is still manageable. | * The sooner we change this kind of thing the better. At the moment, the effort to change is still manageable. | ||
| − | '''Proposal''' - if we are to use the abbreviation as page name | + | '''Proposal (#1)''' - if we are to use the abbreviation as page name |
* Content under [[Safe, sane, and consensual]] be merged with that under [[SSC]]. [[Safe, sane, and consensual]] be dropped. | * Content under [[Safe, sane, and consensual]] be merged with that under [[SSC]]. [[Safe, sane, and consensual]] be dropped. | ||
* The redirect under [[Safe, sane and consensual]] points to SSC. | * The redirect under [[Safe, sane and consensual]] points to SSC. | ||
* All links for [[Safe, sane, and consensual]], [[Safe, sane and consensual]] be altered to point to [[SSC]]. | * All links for [[Safe, sane, and consensual]], [[Safe, sane and consensual]] be altered to point to [[SSC]]. | ||
| − | '''Alternate Proposal''' - if we are to use the full title as page name | + | '''Alternate Proposal (#2)''' - if we are to use the full title as page name |
* The current [[Safe, sane and consensual]] (the redirect) is dropped. | * The current [[Safe, sane and consensual]] (the redirect) is dropped. | ||
* [[Safe, sane, and consensual]] moved to [[Safe, sane and consensual]]. | * [[Safe, sane, and consensual]] moved to [[Safe, sane and consensual]]. | ||
* Content under [[SSC]] merged into [[Safe, sane and consensual]] and [[SSC]] be turned into a redirect. | * Content under [[SSC]] merged into [[Safe, sane and consensual]] and [[SSC]] be turned into a redirect. | ||
* All links for [[SSC]] and [[Safe, sane, and consensual]] be altered to point to [[Safe, sane and consensual]]. | * All links for [[SSC]] and [[Safe, sane, and consensual]] be altered to point to [[Safe, sane and consensual]]. | ||
| + | |||
| + | (Proposal above by [[User:Interesdom]]) | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==Comments== | ||
| + | *I'd be very disinclined to make an abbreviation the main article as in #1. Yes, there should be a single article (with the others as redirects) and my personal preference would be for the target article to be located at [[Safe, sane and consensual]] (option #2). (The comma before the 'and' is, I believe, known as an "Oxford comma" and is - surprisingly - correct grammar!) --[[User:VampWillowTop|VampWillowTop]] 00:08, 20 Jun 2005 (BST) | ||
Revision as of 19:08, 19 June 2005
Proposed changes
Resons for proposals
- 'Safe, sane, and consensual' is grammatically poor: it should be 'Safe, sane and consensual'.
- 'Safe, sane and consensual' is lengthy and cumbersome in links; 'SSC' would be easier.
- RACK has the content for 'Risk Aware Consensual Kink'. It is inconsistent to have the content under 'Safe, sane and consensual' rather than SSC.
- This may be worth thinking about as a general policy issue. For example, should we have content under "M/s" or under "Master/slave", "S&M" or "Sadomasochism".
- SSC is a stub that is neither the full text nor a disambiguation.
- The sooner we change this kind of thing the better. At the moment, the effort to change is still manageable.
Proposal (#1) - if we are to use the abbreviation as page name
- Content under Safe, sane, and consensual be merged with that under SSC. Safe, sane, and consensual be dropped.
- The redirect under Safe, sane and consensual points to SSC.
- All links for Safe, sane, and consensual, Safe, sane and consensual be altered to point to SSC.
Alternate Proposal (#2) - if we are to use the full title as page name
- The current Safe, sane and consensual (the redirect) is dropped.
- Safe, sane, and consensual moved to Safe, sane and consensual.
- Content under SSC merged into Safe, sane and consensual and SSC be turned into a redirect.
- All links for SSC and Safe, sane, and consensual be altered to point to Safe, sane and consensual.
(Proposal above by User:Interesdom)
Comments
- I'd be very disinclined to make an abbreviation the main article as in #1. Yes, there should be a single article (with the others as redirects) and my personal preference would be for the target article to be located at Safe, sane and consensual (option #2). (The comma before the 'and' is, I believe, known as an "Oxford comma" and is - surprisingly - correct grammar!) --VampWillowTop 00:08, 20 Jun 2005 (BST)
